January 6, 2017
Ryan Williams 202-677-7060


DeVos & Puzder Will Make American Economy Stronger


Heather Greenaway
Januaryh 5, 2017

During the last eight years, the U.S. economy has limped along at an average growth rate around 2 percent, the weakest recovery since World War II. Workforce participation is under 38 percent, a depth not seen since the economic malaise of the Carter administration. As a result, middle-class wages have been flat and families are feeling squeezed. These dynamics in the labor force help explain why nearly two-thirds of voters believed the country was headed in the wrong direction on Election Day.

Donald Trump was elected on a promise to Make America Great Again by bringing seismic changes to the political culture in Washington. To succeed, he will have to create stronger growth and rising wages. In picking Betsy DeVos to head up the Department of Education and Andy Puzder to lead the Labor Department, President-elect Trump has sent an early signal about his determination to make American workers and the next generation more competitive.

DeVos and Puzder will challenge the antiquated policies favored by labor union leaders that are inflicting damage on the American economy. While much of the focus on the Trump economic agenda has been on his commitment to end Obama-era regulations and reform the tax code, more attention should be given to the long-term benefits that can result from a better educated and trained workforce.

According to Manpower’s annual Talent Shortage Survey, more than 40 percent of American employers reported having difficulty finding talented workers to fill job openings. This eye-opening finding tracks with the fact that only 40 percent of high school graduates are college or workforce ready, according to the Nation’s Report Card.

DeVos is an ideal candidate to drive a national debate on how to improve the performance of our K-12 schools. For the last 28 years, she has fought in the trenches against the leadership within the teachers unions to break their monopoly on education and give parents a larger voice in where and how their children are educated.

Trump and DeVos are promising to free up $20 billion of federal funding to empower governors to expand school choice. This reform has the potential to revolutionize education at the state and local level. By shifting power from a top-down bureaucracy in Washington that ignores failure and rewards labor unions, the Trump administration will be clearing the way for reforms that will increase accountability within a system that in many cases has protected bad teachers and failing schools.

In the private sector, competition is a force for good that requires company executives to innovate and to hold their share of the market. The same dynamic can be at play in the classroom as traditional public schools, charter schools, private and virtual schools all compete for students.

The demand for school choice in America is high and growing. Today, nearly 3 million students attend charter schools and 1 million are on waiting lists. In Indiana, nearly 35,000 students are participating in the state’s voucher program, a tenfold increase since it was adopted in 2011.

DeVos believes that education dollars should follow the student to the best schools available to them. This is a concept that frightens the unions because it puts trust in parents instead of writing blank checks to an education establishment that is failing to prepare our children for the jobs of the future.

By raising the bar on education and ensuring American businesses have a deep pool of skilled workers to hire, DeVos will help build the foundation for long-term economic growth needed to boost the quality of life of middle-class families.

Similar to DeVos’ commitment to challenge the teachers unions, Puzder, the CEO of CKE Restaurants, has the courage and fortitude to take on the those arguing in favor of an antiquated mindset that threatens to undercut workers with the lowest skill levels that are barely hanging onto the economic ladder. It is sad that the biggest idea the union leaders and Democrat Party have on the economy is to drive up the minimum wage to $15 an hour, ensuring the loss of hundreds of thousands of jobs and accelerating the forces of automation throughout the workforce.

Republicans under the leadership of the Trump administration and inspired leaders like Betsy DeVos and Andy Puzder have the potential to become the voice for workers in America for a simple reason: organized labor and the big-government policies it champions have left behind too many working Americans and created substandard schools that aren’t keeping pace with our economic competitors.

Big change is indeed on the way to Washington, and working families stand to be the biggest beneficiaries.


Heather Greenaway is a national spokesperson for the Workforce Fairness Institute.

To access the op-ed, click here.

The Workforce Fairness Institute is an organization committed to educating voters, employers, employees and citizens about issues affecting the workplace.  To learn more, please visit:

To schedule an interview with a Workforce Fairness Institute representative, please contact Ryan Williams at (202) 677-7060.



Featured Blog

AZ Daily Sun--Coconino Voices: PRO Act legislation would hurt local businesses

— 05.13.2021 —
By: Julie Pastrik Arizona businesses and workers have had an incredibly challenging year given the economic slowdown that followed in the wake of the coronavirus pandemic. However, local businesses and industries across the state are resilient and on the road to a strong recovery that will mean more jobs for Arizona workers and increased economic development to strengthen our communities. That is, as long as Congress does not move forward with potentially devastating legislation that would hurt local employers and employees alike while impeding our state’s economic recovery. Unfortunately, some members of Congress seem determined to do just that by pushing through the Protecting the Right to Organize (PRO) Act. As harmless as the name may sound, the PRO Act would have serious repercussions for local businesses, particularly smaller ones, while undermining long-standing rights for employees and threatening the growing gig economy that has helped provide much-needed income for so many during this time. Arizona is fortunate to have leaders like Senators Mark Kelly and Kyrsten Sinema, who have both refrained from joining the vast majority of their Democratic colleagues in cosponsoring the PRO Act. In a slap in the face to Arizona workers, the PRO Act removes one of the most fundamental rights a worker has when it comes to voting in elections to determine whether to unionize: the secret ballot. Instead, workers could be forced to sign union authorization cards in front of other employees, their employer, or union organizers. This bill would also destroy workers’ right to privacy by allowing unions access to personal information, including their home address and personal phone number. If that doesn’t open the door to union intimidation and harassment, I don’t know what does. As if that was not bad enough, the PRO Act would create major new challenges for Arizona businesses, making it harder for them to create jobs, expand in their communities, and even keep their doors open. It would redefine what it means to be a “joint employer” under national labor law, greatly complicating existing relationships between franchisors and franchisees as well as between business owners, contractors, subcontractors, and vendors and suppliers. At the same time, it would interfere with attorney-client confidentiality and make it much more difficult for small businesses to secure a legal advice on labor issues. Particularly harmful during these times, the PRO Act would apply a failed policy from California to national labor law by using the “ABC” test to determine whether a worker is an independent contractor or employee. This makes it much harder to qualify as an independent contractor, threatening the freedom and flexibility that tens of thousands of Arizonans find in independent contracting and gig economy work. Ultimately, the PRO Act is bad public policy that only works for union leaders to inflate their falling ranks while threatening workers’ rights, undermining small businesses, and jeopardizing a growing part of our economy. This is not a good solution for Arizona, and Senators Sinema and Kelly should stay firm and not cosponsor this misguided legislation.
Read More